What I’m Making: Chocolate Marshmallow Cookies

A blog reader sent me a cookbook and I’ve been spending time reading through the recipes.  This one caught my eye.
See where it says, “Large Marshmallows halved”.  That caught my attention.  I’ve never made cookies with marshmallows except for ones with nuts.

Well, I wanted to try these simply because they sounded really interesting.  Anything that sounds weird or different, is something I want to try.  After not remembering to get marshmallows for three trips for grocery pick up, I finally remembered on the third try…but then I accidentally got small marshmallows.  I needed large marshmallows.  So on the FOURTH try, I got the marshmallows.

The moment I had time, I mixed up a batch.  The batter is thick.

I used my smallest scoop to scoop the batter onto the cookie sheets.

I baked them for 8 minutes…

I took them out of the oven and put a large marshmallow cut in half on each cookie.  Back into the oven they went for 2 minutes.

They came out looking like this…

I pushed the marshmallow down a bit so they looked like this and then let them cool.

I mixed up a batch of frosting.  Using a spoon for the frosting worked best.  Check out Rosie eyeing the cookies.

Here’s how they look…

Kalissa and I both liked them.  We thought they tasted like a Ho-Ho.

Gannon loved them.  What a chocolate mess he was!!

The batch makes about 30 cookies.  Around here, that many gets snapped up FAST!!

They were really good and I will for sure be making these again.

I know someone will ask so I’m including info on the scoops.

HERE is a link to the scoops I use.  I have all three different sizes.  There are others that are cheaper but they don’t have the same construction as these.  They have springs not the same interlocking mechanism at the bottom.

If you try them, let me know what you think of them.  The cookies are cake-like and do taste a bit like Ho-hos.

14 thoughts on “What I’m Making: Chocolate Marshmallow Cookies”

  1. I have a tablespoon cookie scoop from Creative Chief that a use for Christmas cookies. the uniform size makes them look so nice and cook so evenly, the larges sizes look great for everyday cookies. Looks like a good recipe.

  2. When I was little (many many years ago) my mother made what were called “marshmallow teas”. I still have the recipe card with the recipe cut out and taped to it. Anyway, cut a small slash in the top of a marshmallow. Slightly moisten the bottom and set it on a saltine. Bake five minutes in a hot oven. Put strawberry jelly in the hollows formed in the center of the marshmallows. Probably developed when you could only get marshmallows in one size and everyone had saltines.

  3. Carmen Montmarquet

    I wonder how it would be if you took another cookie and put it on top of the marshmallow, it would look like a whoopie pie! Just a thought! Thanks for the yummy recipe, can’t wait tot try it!

  4. Andrea Hickman

    Those look good! There is a recipe on My Recipes from Southern Living called Mississippi Mud Cookies that is very similar. That recipe has chocolate chips too. My children love those cookies.

  5. Cheryl in St. Paul

    My late mother-in-law used to make these. I loved reading your post and loved that they were enjoyed by your beautiful family.

  6. These look yummy – another recipe to put aside for when the grand visit – or I visit them!
    Love and prayers

  7. Could you post the entire recipe including how to mix the frosting? I’m not a baker so I need all the info I can get! LOL These do look yummy!

      1. I see the ingredients listed. Are they all dumped in the bowl at once then just mixed together? So sorry to be a bother.

  8. Pingback: Ask Jo: Quilts, Cookies and Pizza (what an odd combo) | Jo's Country Junction

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top